When you own a small business, one underperforming employee can have a significant impact. Deadlines get missed, customers may be affected, other employees pick up the slack, and before long, you’re spending more time managing the problem than running your business.

It’s tempting to hope things will improve on their own.

Usually, they don’t.

Addressing poor performance doesn’t have to begin with discipline or termination. It starts with understanding the problem, setting clear expectations, and giving the employee a reasonable opportunity to improve.

1. Identify the Real Performance Problem

Before sitting down with the employee, get specific about what’s wrong.

“Your performance isn’t good enough” isn’t particularly helpful.

Instead, identify observable issues:

Are deadlines consistently being missed? Is the quality of work below expectations? Are customers complaining? Is attendance affecting operations? Is the employee failing to complete essential responsibilities?

Separate facts from frustration.

You may be annoyed with the employee, but the conversation should focus on performance and expectations—not personality.

2. Don’t Wait Too Long to Address It

One of the biggest mistakes small-business owners make is waiting.

You notice the problem but hope it will resolve itself. Weeks turn into months, and eventually you’re so frustrated that you’re ready to terminate the employee.

Meanwhile, the employee may not even realize how serious the problem has become.

Address performance concerns early.

A timely conversation gives the employee an opportunity to correct the problem before it becomes more difficult to manage.

3. Have a Direct—but Professional—Conversation

You don’t need to make the conversation intimidating.

You do need to make it clear.

Explain the performance concern, provide specific examples when appropriate, and describe what you expect going forward.

For example:

“We’ve missed three client deadlines this month. I need projects completed by the agreed-upon due dates, and if you believe a deadline is at risk, I need you to communicate that to me before it is missed.”

That’s much more useful than:

“You need to do better.”

Be direct enough that the employee understands the seriousness of the issue without turning the meeting into a personal attack.

4. Find Out What’s Causing the Problem

Poor performance isn’t always caused by a lack of effort.

Ask questions.

Does the employee understand what’s expected?

Do they have the necessary training?

Is the workload realistic?

Are there unclear priorities?

Has something changed?

Is there a communication problem between the employee and manager?

You don’t have to excuse poor performance, but understanding the cause can help you determine the appropriate solution.

Sometimes the employee needs clearer expectations.

Sometimes they need training.

Sometimes they need better management.

And sometimes, despite reasonable support, the employee simply isn’t performing at the required level.

5. Establish Clear Expectations for Improvement

Once you’ve discussed the problem, define what needs to change.

Avoid vague instructions such as:

“Be more productive.”

Instead, establish expectations the employee can understand and that you can evaluate.

What needs to improve?

What does acceptable performance look like?

When should improvement occur?

How will progress be measured?

When will you meet again?

Clarity benefits both the employee and the business.

6. Document the Conversation

Small-business owners sometimes resist documentation because it feels too “corporate.”

It doesn’t have to be.

Documentation creates a record of what was discussed, what the expectations were, and what happened afterward.

Keep documentation factual and professional. Record relevant dates, performance concerns, expectations, follow-up discussions, and progress.

Don’t wait until you’re considering termination to start documenting a performance problem that has existed for six months.

7. Follow Up

Don’t have one conversation and assume the problem is solved.

Schedule a follow-up.

Acknowledge meaningful improvement when you see it. If performance remains below expectations, address that too.

Employees should know where they stand.

If you’re telling yourself for months that an employee is “on their last chance” but you’ve never clearly communicated that there is a serious performance problem, there’s a disconnect.

What If the Employee Doesn’t Improve?

Sometimes coaching, clarification, additional training, and feedback work.

Sometimes they don’t.

If an employee isn’t meeting reasonable performance expectations despite appropriate communication and support, you may eventually need to consider additional action.

Before making significant employment decisions, particularly termination, consider the circumstances carefully. Review your documentation, policies and past practices, and obtain appropriate HR or legal guidance when necessary.

The objective isn’t to keep an employee indefinitely when the arrangement clearly isn’t working.

It’s to make thoughtful, consistent, and well-informed decisions.

Don’t Let a Performance Problem Run Your Business

Managing employees isn’t always comfortable.

But avoiding difficult conversations can allow a manageable performance issue to become a much larger business problem.

Address concerns early. Be specific. Listen. Establish clear expectations. Document appropriately. Follow up.

And recognize when you need help.

Need Help With a Difficult Employee Situation?

You don’t need a full-time HR department to get experienced HR guidance.

I provide Small Business HR Consulting & Advisory to help business owners navigate employee relations, performance management, workplace policies, difficult conversations, and other people challenges.

Schedule a Small Business HR Consultation

Show Less